Blog

What the First Two Trading Days of January Reveal About Stock Market Trends for 2025

Hannah Perry | January 6, 2025

Responsive image

What the First Two Trading Days of January Predict for Stocks in 2025

The onset of a new year often spurs thoughts of financial resolutions, hopes for prosperity, and—it wouldn’t be January without mentioning—the “Santa Claus rally.” However, this year’s stock market performance from Christmas through the second trading day of January has many wondering about future trends, particularly in 2025. Contrary to popular belief, experts indicate that the absence of a Santa Claus rally does not doom the stock market for the year ahead.

The Santa Claus Rally Defined

The term “Santa Claus rally” describes the stock market’s tendency to rise in the final week of December and the first two trading days of January. Historically, this period has been marked by gains in stock prices more frequently than during other times of the year. Unfortunately, this year has not aligned with tradition. Between Christmas 2023 and the second trading day of January 2024, the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) fell by **1.3%**, while the S&P 500 dropped **1.6%**. As we enter 2025, the lack of a robust market performance during this festive period raises concerns.

Wall Street Perspectives

Many investors and analysts on Wall Street believe that failing to achieve a Santa Claus rally typically signals a challenging year ahead for the stock market. However, a closer examination of historical data suggests otherwise. The past shows that the year following a downbeat Santa Claus rally isn’t necessarily doomed to repeat those trends.

Historical Context: What Do the Numbers Say?

Taking a look back, one can consider the last occurrence when the Dow suffered a loss during the Santa Claus rally period, which was back in 2015. Specifically, from Christmas Day in 2015 until the end of the second trading day in 2016, the Dow decreased by **2.2%**. Contrary to expectations, the market rebounded significantly, with the Dow soaring by **15.2%** from the second day of 2016 onward. This example illustrates that an initial downturn does not guarantee a poor performance throughout the entire year.

Understanding Probabilities

According to historical averages based on data from the Dow dating back to its inception in 1896, the market has manifested positive returns in **65.6%** of the years. More intriguingly, periods that included a Santa Claus rally resulted in a slightly higher probability of a rising market, about **66.7%** of the time. Conversely, the odds of a rally after a Santa Claus decline stood at **60.7%**. However, these differences are not statistically significant at the **95% confidence level**, which casts doubt on the theory that Santa’s absence bears a substantial impact on the year’s overall performance.

Why This Matters

Analysts suggest that any perceived correlation between the market’s performance during the Santa Claus rally and its success over subsequent months may not be statistically valid. Even if a correlation existed, the widespread awareness could diminish any discernible pattern. Consequently, the economic landscape, corporate earnings, and broader market dynamics play more crucial roles in determining stock market performance than the familiar seasonal tendencies.

Conclusion: The Bottom Line

The evidence is compelling: what the stock market does in the first two trading days of January holds little predictive power over its trajectory for the rest of the year. While the absence of a Santa Claus rally might induce panic among some investors, history supports the notion that the performance during this period is not a reliable indicator of future gains or losses. Investors should remain focused on fundamental factors and broader economic conditions instead of getting trapped in the myths surrounding historical trends.

As we step into 2025, it’s essential to remember that market dynamics can shift rapidly, and the performance we see now is just one piece of a larger puzzle. By bringing careful analysis and a diversified approach to investments, market participants can navigate opportunities, regardless of whether Santa made his appearance this year.