Blog

Wall Street’s Speculative Stocks Plunge: The Reckoning for Retail Investors

Hannah Perry | January 9, 2025

Responsive image

Wall Street’s Riskiest Stocks Face Reckoning Amid Selloff

On Wednesday, retail traders and investors witnessed a dramatic plunge in some of the most speculative stocks in the market, marking a potential “day of reckoning” for those who had been relying on risky investments. The selloff was sparked by comments from Nvidia Corp. (NVDA) CEO Jensen Huang at a tech conference, where he indicated that quantum computing might still be two decades away from realization. This prompted a steep decline in stocks related to quantum computing, as well as a wider fallout across various sectors favored by retail investors.

Quantum Computing Stocks Take the Hit

The initial wave of the selloff struck quantum computing stocks particularly hard. Companies such as Rigetti Computing Inc. (RGTI) and IonQ Inc. (IONQ) saw their shares plummet by as much as 50% within the day—registering their largest single-day falls in history, according to FactSet data. Other stocks in the quantum sector, including Quantum Computing Inc. (QUBT), suffered similarly severe declines.

Farzin Azarm, a managing director at Mizuho Securities USA, mentioned that the rush of retail investors to cover margin calls further exacerbated the selloff. In December, Thomas Peterffy, founder and Chairman of Interactive Brokers Group Inc. (IBKR), highlighted a 16% increase in margin loans on their platform over the past three months. Azarm stated, “The retail crowd is facing a day of reckoning today. They had been buying into these extremely speculative names, but now that’s starting to unwind.”

The Impact Beyond Quantum Stocks

The fallout from this situation was not isolated; a FTSE-Russell index tracking heavily shorted U.S. stocks experienced a sharp decline of over 5% on Wednesday. Sectors like aerospace and space exploration were swept into the storm, with stocks such as Intuitive Machines Inc. (LUNR) dropping more than 5% and Archer Aviation (ACHR) falling nearly 6%. Additionally, nuclear-power stocks like NANO Nuclear Energy Inc. (NNE) decreased by more than 11%, while NuScale Power Corp. (SMR) was down more than 9%.

Broader Trends Among Retail Traders

Retail traders have been particularly active in the market lately, contributing significantly to speculative investments. Trading volume surged earlier in the week, with the Nasdaq Composite reaching nearly 14 billion shares on Tuesday, a record high since tracking began in 1995. However, trading activity slowed on Wednesday, although data suggested that around 55% of market activity in the past two weeks was tied to platforms typically utilized by retail investors. Azarm noted, “This is massive. Even during the 2021 melt-up, we hardly saw anything this elevated.” The trend toward penny stocks has also become increasingly pronounced—Joe Saluzzi of Themis Trading indicated that there has been unusually high volume in shares trading at $1 or less.

Speculative Stocks and Economic Climate

The resurgence of speculation in various sectors has been evident since the 2020 election cycle. Rising yields on 10-year Treasury notes, now approaching their highest levels since late 2023, have created nervousness in broader markets like the S&P 500, Nasdaq, and Dow Jones Industrial Average, which have all experienced declines this week.

While rising interest rates might alter the market’s risk-reward calculations, they appeared not to factor into the valuations of many retail traders who leaned heavily on speculative stocks. Steve Sosnick, chief strategist at Interactive Brokers, commented, “Frankly, I think those who went heavily into speculative quantum stocks are getting clobbered, which is now spilling into other speculative names.”

Ongoing Market Froth

Despite the recent havoc, some segments of the market remain rife with speculative excesses. Julian Klymochko, CEO and chief investment officer of Accelerate, pointed to companies like MicroStrategy Inc. (MSTR) as exemplifying this trend. As a vehicle for Bitcoin investment, MicroStrategy has seen its stock fluctuate significantly in correlation with Bitcoin prices, but still trades at a notable premium relative to its net asset value, primarily consisting of its Bitcoin holdings.

As the dust settles from Wednesday’s selloff, many investors are left to ponder the sustainability of such speculative investments in an evolving economic landscape marked by rising interest rates and potential market recalibrations.